COMPARISON
MT4 vs MT5 for automated trading
VERDICT
For a new automated system, use MT5. MT4 is no longer developed, its backtester is weaker and more optimistic, and the only real reason to stay on it is a library of EAs you already own.
| Criterion | MetaTrader 4 | MetaTrader 5 |
|---|---|---|
| EA language | MQL4 | MQL5. Not compatible: EAs must be rewritten |
| Backtester | Single-threaded, known to be optimistic | Multi-threaded, real-tick modelling available |
| Timeframes | 9 | 21 |
| Account model | Hedging only | Netting or hedging, broker-dependent |
| Development status | Effectively frozen; not licensed to new brokers | Actively developed |
| Instrument coverage | FX and CFDs | Adds exchange-traded instruments and depth of market |
An MT4 EA cannot run on MT5
MQL4 and MQL5 differ so much that no conversion tool gives a working result for anything beyond a simple script. An .ex4 file will never appear in the MT5 Navigator. That catches people who assume the two platforms are versions of one product: see EA not in Navigator.
In practice, choosing the platform is choosing the EA library, because it decides which programs can run.
The backtester difference matters more than the feature list
MT4's strategy tester is single-threaded, and its modelling is well known for producing results better than reality. MT5 supports real-tick modelling and multi-threaded optimisation. That does not make a backtest trustworthy, but it removes one source of inflated results.
Real ticks only go back as far as the broker keeps them. When we built a Strategy Tester report on an Exness demo server, real tick history began on 11 Aug 2026. Anything earlier had to run on generated ticks ("Every tick" mode), which is less exact for a scalper.
Neither tester models spread widening, slippage or the broker minimum lot realistically unless you set it up to, so the assumptions that inflate results apply to both.
Netting accounts catch people moving from MT4
MT4 is always hedging: several positions on the same symbol stay open side by side. MT5 may be netting, depending on the broker, and then opposing orders offset into a single net position.
An EA written for hedging can behave unpredictably on a netting account, so check the account type before running an unfamiliar system. See hedging.
Other comparisons
- Choosing a gold trading bot: the criteria that matterAsk for maximum drawdown, sample size, whether any data was held back, where the stop loss i…
- Copy trading vs trading signalsIf you want automation, choose copy trading. Signals are not automated, and the delay betwee…
- Trading bot vs manual tradingAutomation wins on consistency, availability and record-keeping. Manual wins on adapting to …
- Grid trading vs trend followingTrend following, on risk grounds alone. Both lose in the wrong regime, but a trend system lo…
Further reading
Educational information only, not financial advice. Trading leveraged products carries substantial risk of loss. Last updated 2026-11-11.