RESEARCH

Looking for expert advisor reviews on Reddit?

Going to a community instead of a sales page is the right instinct. Those threads are reliably good at some things, and they get two things wrong in the same way every time.

Short answer

Trading communities are excellent at identifying scams, martingale systems and vendors who vanish, because bad outcomes get reported loudly. They are poor at identifying good systems, because profitable traders rarely post, survivors are outnumbered, and almost nobody reports a boring result. Use them as a filter to rule products out, not to pick one.

What Reddit threads are good at

  • Naming scams. A vendor who takes money and disappears gets reported quickly and permanently.
  • Spotting martingale. Somebody always posts the equity curve after it ends, and those posts are searchable.
  • Support after the sale. Whether a vendor answers messages once you have paid is exactly what customers report.
  • Platform problems. On broker quirks, FIFO errors and symbol naming, community answers are often better than the documentation.

That makes a community the right first stop, and a useful filter. Use it to rule things out.

The two biases built into every thread

Winners do not post. Someone quietly running a system that works has no reason to advertise it and a good reason not to: an edge that gets shared gets diluted. So the posts you read come disproportionately from people with a complaint or something to sell.

A good month proves nothing, and gets reported anyway. The most common post in these threads is a screenshot of a profitable first few weeks. Every strategy has those, including the ones that end accounts, and a martingale produces the most convincing ones of all.

How to read a thread well

  • Sort by controversial or by oldest. The top comment is popular, which is not the same as correct.
  • Look for the drawdown question. Threads where someone asked about the worst period and got a real answer are worth ten enthusiastic threads.
  • Check post history. An account that only posts about one product is promoting it.
  • Weight duration over enthusiasm. "Six months including a bad August" beats "up 40% this month" by a wide margin.
  • Note what is absent. If nobody in a long thread mentions position sizing, nobody has checked.

The questions that get useful answers

Vague questions get opinions and specific ones get facts. Ask whether it increases lot size after a loss, whether there is a verified signal covering a drawdown, and what happened to anyone who ran it through a losing month. Those have checkable answers.

That is the same list we publish as seven checks for any EA, and we answer all seven for our own product on that page, including the ones where the honest answer is "not yet". To check a marketplace listing, what to check on MQL5 Market covers the fields that are hard to game.

If you would rather check a vendor than ask about one, everything we measured is on the engine page with the trade counts beside it, including the strategies that were tested and switched off. We also publish the test it failed: we wrote the test down in advance, ran the four strategies in the bot on their own, on gold from 2019 to 2024, years they were not tuned on, and none of the six years was positive.

Common questions

Are trading bots discussed honestly on Reddit?

Mostly yes, and that is their value. Unhappy customers post, blown accounts get screenshotted, and vendors who disappear get named. Discount affiliate promotion, which is common and not always disclosed, and the survivor pattern where someone posts a good first month as though it settled anything. A month is not a sample, whoever is reporting it.

Why do people say all forex EAs are scams?

Because the visible ones often are, and because the way they fail sticks in the memory. A martingale EA that runs beautifully for five months and then wipes out an account produces one very loud post, while a boring system returning a modest amount produces none. That skews what people see. The accurate version is narrower: most heavily marketed EAs are not worth buying, and that does not make the whole category fraudulent.

What should I ask in a trading subreddit before buying an EA?

Ask specific, checkable things rather than "is this good". Does it increase position size after a loss. Does it publish a verified signal covering a drawdown. Has anyone run it through a losing month, and what happened. Those questions get useful answers because they have factual replies, whereas "is X profitable" reliably produces opinion.

Further reading

Our answers to all seven checksChecking an MQL5 listing

Educational information only, not financial advice. Trading leveraged products carries substantial risk of loss. Last updated 2026-08-19.