QUESTION
What is a good win rate for a trading bot?
SHORT ANSWER
Win rate alone tells you nothing. At a 2:1 reward-to-risk ratio break-even is about 34%, so a 40% win rate is a working system. At 1:2 break-even is 67%, and an 80% win rate can still lose money once costs are counted.
The number that matters is expectancy: win rate combined with the average win and the average loss. A 35% win rate at 3:1 makes 0.4R per trade. A 60% win rate at 0.5:1 makes −0.1R, losing money while winning most of its trades.
Vendors still advertise win rate more than anything else, because it is easy to understand and easy to make look good. A system that takes tiny profits and lets losers run can show 90% and be one trade from disaster. Most martingale products look exactly like that.
On live client accounts, the bot's accuracy has been 60–80%. Our backtest win rate is 47% over 1,297 trades, and it means little without the result beside it: in the same backtest the average month made +$274.60 on $1,000, each month tested on its own, with 17 of 22 months profitable and a worst drop of $860 inside one month.
How many trades before the number means anything
Thirty trades will show a very large effect and nothing else. A hundred starts to tell you something, and by several hundred the win rate is steady enough to treat as an estimate. A vendor quoting a precise win rate after a few weeks of live trading is quoting noise: see sample size.
For the same reason our engine scores strategies on the Wilson lower bound instead of the raw rate. A strategy that won its only two trades shows a 100% win rate and deserves no confidence at all.
A win rate also needs a baseline. Over all 383 replay trades of our bot from 2019 to Oct 2026, its entries won 31.6% of the time. A random entry with the same stop and target won 31.5%. On that test, the entries carried no information.
Related questions
- Are trading bots profitable?Some are, most are not. The profitable ones make modest returns with real drawdowns, well below …
- Why is my trading bot losing money?Four causes cover nearly every case: the strategy was overfitted to its backtest, costs were not…
- How long before a trading bot shows results?A year or more. A bot averaging ten trades a month needs several hundred trades before its win r…
Further reading
Educational information only, not financial advice. Trading leveraged products carries substantial risk of loss. Last updated 2026-11-11.